Deputy Gavin St Pier says public perception, not who is best for the job, influenced decisions.
Deputy Gavin St Pier says he is 'neither surprised nor disappointed' by not being able to regain his seat in the Policy & Resources Committee.
The ex-Treasury Lead resigned from the senior committee earlier this month to see if he had States backing, following a police investigation into harassment allegations, which he denies.
He told Island FM:
"So long as there is an ongoing live investigation, the States by majority felt that was the most important consideration, rather than experience."
He also said that 'one could very much see it as an opportunity' that he wasn't re-elected.
Policy and Resources' preferred candidate, Deputy Niles got the seat in the top committee, with 23 votes.
Andrew Niles replaces St Pier in Policy and Resources Committee

Guernsey Museums report a 3% increase in visitor numbers
Sewage outfall fixed on Guernsey's east coast
Successful start to Guernsey Ports renewable heating oil conversion
Guernsey's Animal Shelter nurses oiled seabird
Home Affairs needs millions to maintain Guernsey's frontline services
New savings scheme for Guernsey children in care
Alderney celebrates two awards at Britain in Bloom
Guernsey reservoir walk closes due to storm damage