St Helier parishioners have refused a government offer of £6.5m for land at Westmount to create the access road to the new hospital.
The deal was presented to ratepayers at a Parish Assembly.
Town Hall procureurs had said the offer represented 'good value'.
We have taken independent advice and we concluded that this is a reasonable offer, which under the circumstances represents value to parishioners, so we believe it important that the Parish Assembly has an opportunity to consider this offer at this time." - Mr. Peter Pearce, Procureur du Bien Public.
It included a land swap for the bowling club, which is set to move to Warwick Farm.
Parishioners voted 14 in favour, 47 against the deal.
Senator Lyndon Farnham, the Chair of the Our Hospital Political Oversight Group, says the compulsory purchase option must now be used.
"We would, of course, have preferred to reach an agreement with the parish of St Helier and their parishioners for the purchase of the land essential for the Island's new hospital.
In order to ensure that we keep this important project on time and within budget, we must now proceed with the compulsory purchase process to acquire the Parish of St Helier land as agreed by the States Assembly in October (P.80/2021). As part of this process, the sale price will now be set by an independent board of arbitrators.
We will continue to work as closely as possible with the Parish authorities to ensure continued progress so that all Islanders can benefit from the new hospital in 2026."

DFDS adds Poole sailing to get stranded islanders to Jersey
Long-term lease secures Blue Note's future for Jersey's live music scene
Now-illegal Jersey fishing nets to prevent drone strikes in Ukraine
Islanders reminded to check tides after Portelet rescue
Rule change for pet travel to France
Health degrees for islanders offering guaranteed employment
Complaints about Jersey's public service more than double
Islanders asked to share experience of domestic abuse cases