Deputies vote to turn the quarry into the next reservoir while rubble and builders' waste will be dumped near the Longue Hougue reclamation.
Stone extraction at Les Vardes quarry on the west coast has stopped for now, as Ronez moves that work to Chouet.
But the firm is still using the quarry for crushing stone, so turning it into a reservoir is some years away.
Deputy Lindsay de Sausmarez told deputies they were voting for the long term provision of drinking water, but deputy Marc Leadbeater was unconvinced:
"There's certainly been no evidence we have a water storage crisis.
"We have a housing crisis, we admit that don't we, we know that.
"But we haven't had a hosepipe ban since I was a kid."
In a separate vote, following a successful amendment by deputy Mark Helyar, who also questioned the need for such storage capacity, inert waste will be dumped at Black Rock.
This is an area of the South Side of the Bridge, near to the northern end of Longue Hougue and its use here will help the regeneration of the Bridge by providing land.
In the meantime, rubble and builders waste will continue be stockpiled.
Guernsey parishes plan Liberation weekend celebrations
150 tonnes of food waste going to landfill in Guernsey
Bed blocking leads to longer surgical waiting times in Guernsey
Seasonal beach restrictions for dogs and horses begin again in Guernsey
Occupation artefacts feature on new Guernsey stamp series
Let wildflowers grow: CI gardeners key to pollinator recovery
Bergerac will return to Jersey for second series
Deputies warned that Guernsey's minimum wage is lagging behind Jersey's
