£466m Hospital Plans Rejected

Monday, 14 January 2019 12:17

Plans for Jersey's new hospital have been rejected by the Environment Minister.

The £466 million development has been denied planning permission for the second time in 12 months.

It follows a second public inquiry and consultation with hospital staff and local residents.

The States has revealed £38,279,051 has already been spent pursuing the existing scheme.

Independent planning inspector, Philip Stadden, recommended the application be refused unless it was found to be in the public interest to build the hospital on the site, outweighing the clashes with the Island Plan.

Environment Minister, Deputy John Young, has backed those recommendations of the hospital planning inspector, who said the building would be too big for the site, harm neighbouring properties and impact on heritage.

The inspector also said there's not one 'stand out' alternative site, and that they'd all come with their own set of 'significant adverse environmental effects'.

Environment Minister, Deputy John Young, says it's not been an easy decision:

"This has been a very challenging decision and I have reluctantly refused this application. As concluded by the inspector, I believe this application site is not quite large enough to comfortably accommodate the proposed scheme. A different application may overcome these issues."

The Health Minister, Deputy Richard Renouf, says it is now up to politicians to decide whether to stick with the current Hospital site, or 'go back to square one'.

"We're really in a very complex situation now, where there seems to be no site in the island that would be acceptable in planning terms.

"The States have got to get together and we've got to work out where's the public interest in this? Because we've got to build it somewhere!

"What compromises do we have to accept to build ourselves a new hospital?"

Despite planning permission for the current site being rejected for a second time in 12 months, Deputy Renouf says it could still go here.

"From what I've read so far (of the planning inspector's report) it still remains the most sustainable option - more so than other sites."

More from Jersey News

Jury finds Shay John Bester guilty of offences including rape

Shay John Bester has been found guilty, after going on trial for offences including six counts of rape against three young, vulnerable females.
African community groups express 'disappointment' with Deputy Ozouf sentencing

Friends of Africa Jersey and the Kenyans in Jersey Committee have come together to express their disappointment following Deputy Philip Ozouf's sentencing, and are calling for increased protection for workers who speak out about exploitation.
Island Energy to return to Royal Court over Mont Pinel gas explosion

Island Energy is set to return to the Royal Court to enter pleas after being charged by the Health and Safety Inspectorate over a gas explosion at Mont Pinel.
Jersey to introduce legal limit for PFAS in drinking water

A legal limit for PFAS in Jersey's drinking water will be introduced for the first time.
Jersey Electricity drops St Martin solar farm idea

Jersey Electricity has dropped plans for a solar farm on land in St Martin belonging to the King.
PPC won't move to block Deputy's return to States Assembly

The committee that oversees States Members' conduct says it won't being a proposition to further suspend Deputy Philip Ozouf following his conviction for immigration offences.
Jersey's next government urged to create laws preventing exploitation of workers

Charities in Jersey are urging politicians to prioritise drawing up laws to abolish modern-day slavery.
Philip Ozouf sentenced to 120 hours community service

Deputy Philip Ozouf has been sentenced to 120 hours community service and ordered to pay £5,000 for immigration offences.